UPSC CSE · Polity and governance
Federalism, Emergencies and Local Government: UPSC Notes
Understand Centre–State powers, Articles 352/356/360, Panchayats and municipalities. Compare approval rules, terms, reservations and planning committees.
Ask which level can act—and by which route
Indian federalism distributes authority between the Union and States. Local self-government adds constitutionally recognised rural and urban institutions. A useful answer must identify the subject, the competent institution, the enabling provision and the conditions. “This is a State subject” is the beginning of the analysis, not always its conclusion.
The core rules
- The Seventh Schedule contains Union, State and Concurrent Lists. Article 246A creates a special GST framework. Do not force every subject into a simplified three-list rule.
- Parliament can legislate on a State subject through specified routes, including Articles 249, 250, 252 and 253. These routes have different triggers and durations.
- Article 352 is a national emergency. Article 356 concerns failure of constitutional machinery in a State. Article 360 is a financial emergency. Their approval and renewal rules are not interchangeable.
- Article 358 concerns Article 19 in a war/external-aggression emergency, subject to its conditions. Article 359 concerns enforcement of specified rights. Articles 20 and 21 are excluded from its suspension power.
- Panchayat and municipal terms are normally five years from their first meeting. Early dissolution does not normally give the replacement body a fresh five-year term.
- Schedules XI and XII list subjects, while State legislation determines actual local powers. State Election Commissions and State Finance Commissions perform different functions.
Centre–State relations
Legislative competence: first the rule, then the exception
Article 246 allocates competence with reference to the Seventh Schedule. Parliament’s residuary power under Article 248 is subject to Article 246A. A subject’s location is crucial, but a special constitutional route may permit Union legislation in a State field.
| Provision | Trigger | Duration or consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Article 249 | Rajya Sabha resolves by at least two-thirds of members present and voting that legislation on a specified State subject is necessary or expedient in the national interest | Resolution lasts up to one year and can be renewed. Law ceases to have effect to the extent of the exceptional competence six months after the resolution ceases, preserving earlier things done or omitted |
| Article 250 | A national emergency is in operation | Exceptional State-list law-making. The law’s relevant operation ends six months after the emergency ceases, with savings for earlier acts or omissions |
| Article 252 | Legislatures of two or more States consent to parliamentary legislation on a State subject | Other States may adopt it. An affected State legislature cannot itself amend or repeal the parliamentary Act |
| Article 253 | Implementation of a treaty, agreement, convention or specified international decision | Parliament has treaty-implementation competence. Do not import Article 252’s State-consent requirement |
Article 249 uses Rajya Sabha, not a joint sitting or a simple Lok Sabha resolution. Article 252 uses State consent, but does not hand amendment of the resulting parliamentary law back to each State.
Conflict between laws
Article 254 addresses repugnancy in the Concurrent field. Under its clause (2), a State law reserved for and receiving presidential assent may prevail in that State despite the specified conflict with an earlier parliamentary law or existing law. Parliament can subsequently override it. Do not generalise this into “presidential assent lets a State legislate on any Union subject.” Legislative competence must still be examined.
Finance and coordination
Article 263 provides for an Inter-State Council when the President considers it in the public interest. The Council’s contemplated functions include inquiry, advice and coordination. It is not the Supreme Court’s Article 131 judicial jurisdiction.
Under Article 293, a State with a relevant outstanding Union loan or Union-guaranteed loan needs Union consent for borrowing in the circumstances specified. Do not convert this into “every State borrowing always requires consent regardless of its debt position.” Finance Commission recommendations, grants and borrowing controls are separate mechanisms.
Consent has a defined legal effect
Two States ask Parliament to enact a law under Article 252. One later decides to change the parliamentary scheme by passing its own amendment. Does initial State consent create this unilateral power?
Article 252 permits parliamentary legislation after the specified State resolutions.
Its amendment and repeal route remains parliamentary, in the manner provided by the Article.
No. Consent to the original legislation does not authorise unilateral State amendment of that Act.
Emergency provisions
Compare the three before learning the details
| Feature | Article 352 | Article 356 | Article 360 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ground | War, external aggression or armed rebellion threatening the security of India or part of it | Government of a State cannot be carried on according to the Constitution | Threat to financial stability or credit of India or part of it |
| Initial parliamentary approval | Within one month | Within two months | Within two months |
| Approval majority | Majority of total membership and at least two-thirds present and voting in each House | Ordinary majority for the resolutions | Ordinary majority for the resolutions |
| Continuation after approval | Six-month renewals | Six-month extensions, normally subject to a three-year outer limit and additional conditions beyond one year | No six-month renewal requirement in the constitutional text |
| Key safeguard | Written decision of Union Cabinet. Lok Sabha disapproval mechanism | High Court powers cannot be assumed. Judicial review and constitutional limits remain | Financial directions may include specified salary reductions |
Dissolution qualification: the Articles contain special arrangements where Lok Sabha is dissolved during the relevant period, including Rajya Sabha approval and a deadline linked to the reconstituted Lok Sabha’s first sitting. Learn the ordinary one/two-month comparison first, but do not state it as exceptionless.
Identify the ground before applying the procedure.
Article 352: national emergency
The President requires the Union Cabinet’s decision communicated in writing. An emergency can cover the whole of India or only part. For continuation, both Houses must approve at the special majority prescribed by Article 352. Lok Sabha can disapprove continuation, requiring revocation. The emergency does not automatically dissolve every State Assembly.
Article 356: constitutional machinery in a State
The President may act on a Governor’s report or otherwise. The proclamation may place legislative powers of the State under parliamentary authority, but cannot assume High Court powers or suspend constitutional provisions relating to High Courts.
Beyond one year, continuation requires both relevant constitutional conditions: a national emergency operating in the specified territorial manner, and Election Commission certification of the difficulty of holding Assembly elections. These conditions do not remove the normal three-year outer limit. A law made under Article 357 does not simply disappear when the proclamation ends. It continues until altered, repealed or amended by a competent authority.
Article 358 versus Article 359
| Question | Article 358 | Article 359 |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Article 19’s restriction on State law-making/executive action is relaxed within the Article’s conditions | Court enforcement of specified Part III rights may be suspended by presidential order |
| Emergency ground | War or external aggression, not armed rebellion | Can operate during a national emergency, subject to the order and constitutional limits |
| Separate presidential order? | The Article’s operation does not require the same kind of separate rights-enforcement order | Yes. Identify the rights, period and territorial scope in the order |
| Important qualification | Protected law must carry the required emergency-related recital. Executive action must be under such a law | Articles 20 and 21 cannot be included. The order must be laid before each House |
For advanced statements, Article 359(1A) also addresses the specified rights’ constraints on qualifying laws and executive action while an order operates. Therefore, “Article 359 has no legislative consequences at all” is too sweeping. Keep the elementary distinction between right and remedy, but read the additional clauses when the question asks about legal effects.
Article 360: financial emergency
Directions can require financial propriety and specified reductions in salaries and allowances, including those of Supreme Court and High Court judges under the constitutional provision. Do not import Article 352’s six-month renewal rule or Article 356’s State-government framework into Article 360.
Panchayats and municipalities
Institutions and functions
| Concept | Constitutional starting point | Distinction |
|---|---|---|
| Gram Sabha | Persons registered in the electoral rolls for the village within the Panchayat area | Not merely the elected Panchayat members |
| Panchayat tiers | Village, intermediate and district levels. Intermediate tier need not be constituted in a State with population not exceeding twenty lakh | Local design has constitutional qualifications and territorial exceptions |
| Rural devolution | Article 243G and Eleventh Schedule’s 29 matters | State legislation empowers Panchayats. Listing is not automatic complete transfer |
| Urban categories | Nagar Panchayat for transitional area, Municipal Council for smaller urban area, Municipal Corporation for larger urban area | Article 243Q includes an industrial-township exception |
| Urban devolution | Article 243W and Twelfth Schedule’s 18 matters | Again, read the State-law empowerment provision |
| Ward Committees | Municipalities with population of three lakh or more under Article 243S | Not the same population test as metropolitan planning |
Subject lists alone do not transfer every function.
Representation, terms, elections and finance
At least one-third of directly elected Panchayat seats are reserved for women, including seats reserved for SC/ST women. At least one-third of Panchayat chairperson offices at each level are reserved for women. These constitutional minimums are not a ceiling preventing States from providing more. Municipal reservation provisions should be read separately under Article 243T. Do not automatically copy every Panchayat chairperson formula into them.
A Panchayat or municipality normally runs five years from its first meeting. Elections must ordinarily be completed before expiry, or within six months of dissolution. If the remainder is less than six months, the Constitution does not require an election for that short remainder. A body elected after premature dissolution serves the remaining period. Municipalities must receive a reasonable opportunity of being heard before dissolution under Article 243U.
The State Election Commission supervises local electoral rolls and elections. The Governor appoints the State Election Commissioner, whose removal safeguard is that of a High Court judge. Service conditions cannot be varied to the Commissioner’s disadvantage after appointment. This is distinct from the Election Commission of India’s responsibilities.
The Governor constitutes a State Finance Commission every five years under Article 243I. It reviews Panchayat finances. Article 243Y extends the review to municipalities. Taxing powers, assignments, grants and funds require the relevant legal framework. A Panchayat does not invent an unrestricted tax merely because the Constitution recognises it. Article 243Z concerns legislative provision for municipal accounts and audit.
Planning committees: keep the fractions separate
| Body | Composition point | Role |
|---|---|---|
| District Planning Committee, Article 243ZD | At least four-fifths elected by and from elected district-level Panchayat and municipal members, with the specified rural–urban proportionality | Consolidates local plans and prepares a draft district development plan |
| Metropolitan Planning Committee, Article 243ZE | At least two-thirds elected by and from elected municipal members and Panchayat chairpersons in the metropolitan area, with the specified proportionality | Prepares a draft metropolitan development plan |
A metropolitan area has a constitutional population threshold of ten lakh or more and other definitional requirements. Do not confuse 3 lakh: Ward Committees, 10 lakh: metropolitan area, 4/5: DPC, and 2/3: MPC.
An early election does not reset the clock
A municipality first meets on 1 July 2027, is dissolved early, and a replacement is elected in 2030. Does the replacement automatically run until 2035?
The normal term is measured from the original body’s first meeting.
After premature dissolution, the replacement serves the remainder of that term.
No. The original normal term ends in 2032. The replacement does not obtain a fresh five years merely because it was newly elected.
Original practice
1 · Special State-list legislation
Which parliamentary event can activate Article 249’s route for a specified State subject?
Show the explanation
A identifies the wrong House and threshold. B is not a constitutional trigger. C states the required parliamentary trigger, with the national-interest condition. D concerns local finances, not Article 249 competence.
2 · Financial emergency
After a financial-emergency proclamation has obtained the required parliamentary approval, which statement about continuation is correct?
Show the explanation
A imports the national-emergency rule. B invents a fixed one-year expiry. C confuses financial emergency with Article 356. D correctly identifies the distinct continuation framework.
3 · Gram Sabha
A village booklet defines Gram Sabha as “only the elected members of the village Panchayat.” What is the correct replacement?
Show the explanation
A follows the constitutional definition. B adds an ownership and tax qualification. C substitutes a different elected institution. D ignores electoral registration and the defined area.
4 · Planning fraction
Which minimum elected proportion is correctly matched with the planning committee?
Show the explanation
A understates the DPC minimum. B is correct under Article 243ZD. C understates the MPC minimum of two-thirds. D incorrectly makes the entire MPC necessarily elected under the constitutional rule.
Six recall checks
Questions to settle
Does a State-list entry completely prevent Parliament from legislating on it?
No. The Constitution provides specified exceptional routes with different conditions.
Does the Eleventh Schedule automatically transfer all 29 subjects to every Panchayat?
No. Article 243G envisages empowerment through State legislation.
Does an early local election always give a new five-year term?
No. A replacement following premature dissolution generally serves the remainder of the original term.
Continue your Polity revision
Compare emergency effects on rights, Union and State institutions, and Election Commission versus other constitutional bodies. For revision, reproduce the three-emergency table from memory before your next Polity practice session.
Sources and scope
Original Exam27 study draft based on Parts IX, IXA, XI and XVIII. Articles 246–254, 263, 293, 352–360. And Schedules VII, XI and XII in the official Constitution. Territorial exceptions to Parts IX and IXA require separate attention in a question about an excluded area. Examples are hypothetical and newly authored.
Put it into practice
Read a topic? Test it now.
Free mock tests in the real exam pattern, with a solution for every question.
Written and reviewed by the exam27 team. Check the official notice for exam dates and rules.